Changes for
The Homeowners Principle Residents Deduction

​    In the past 50 years or so one thing has always been guaranteed by the government and that is the Principle Residents Deduction. If you bought a home to live in with your family, when you sold that home any profit made from the sale of that home was tax free. Claiming this deduction was simple, really you didn’t have to do anything, it wasn’t even reported on your tax return.

    Well in 2016 this changed. In a move that many people may find unexpected the government has made it so that in order to claim the Principle Residents Deduction one must now report the sale of your home on your tax return. If you report the sale then the Principle Residents Deduction can be claimed and there will be no Capital Gains charged on any profit.

    When I first heard of this I could see the government’s intentions. To me it sounded like a fact finding mission to determine how many people might be abusing the Principle Residents Deduction. With the real estate markets as out of control as they have been, it is natural that the number of people flipping homes has increased immensely. With that increase there has been an increase in the number of people trying to take advantage of the best tax break there is, the Principle Residents Deduction. In the last year the number of people who have come to my office and asked “How Long do I have to live in a house for it to be tax free?” has tripled or more. I hear the question almost every week.

    The problem is right now there is no hard fast rule. Some people say a year, some people say six months, but the truth is it all comes down to intent. If you buy a place with the intent to fix it up and sell it, then you are technically subject to Capital Gains. If you buy several places in a row to fix up and sell, it is then a business and you can be subject to full tax on any profit. The government has had no way to monitor these sales, hence the new requirement to declare the sale on your return. This would allow them to determine how many people are selling multiple homes in a row and not having to pay tax on any of them.

    Unfortunately this makes sense to me because one can argue that with the present market someone could move every year, easily make $100k in tax free income, and just say I lived in the house for a year so you can’t touch me. Essentially they could make a pretty good living and never pay a penny of tax. The government wants to know how much they are losing to this. The rule was not meant to target home owners who are buying and selling their house every four or five years just because they want to move, it was to target those who are abusing the rule in order to make a tax free profit.

    This fact finding mission, I believe, is going to lead to a change in the Tax Laws. A more clearly defined Principle Residents Deduction will, most likely, be going on the books. It may limit the number of times you can claim the deduction, such as once every 2 to 4 years, or it may require you to provide more information if you are found to be selling your home too often.

    My biggest problem came when I looked at the way this fact finding mission was going to be enforced. Basically Canada Revenue has said that if you fail to report the sale of your home on you next year’s tax return they can completely disallow the Principle Residents Deduction. Naturally this would be a disaster to most people, for some costing tens of thousands of dollars in tax. They have always allowed for some leniency for people who might have been unaware of the change, but in this case the only leniency they are providing is a clause that says if you forget to claim the home sale, or if you don’t file that year at all, you can change or late file your return, voluntarily claim the deduction, but then be subject to an up to $8000 penalty depending on the amount of profit made on the home. Effectively by putting these penalties in place, they are punishing everyone who sells a home and fails to report it, even those who legitimately had no intent to avoid taxes, they were just unaware.

    Another disturbing fact revealed in my research is how the government has also gone out of its way to mention that people renting out part of their home, or maintaining a home office for their business, may find the portion of the house being written off subject to Capital Gains. In the past as long as the portion being written off was reasonable and less than 50% it wouldn’t effect the Principle Residents Deduction. The end results from this may be that people renting rooms in their house may stop renting them all together, helping to even further decrease the housing available to lower income people. Small businesses that can only afford to be operated out of the house on start-up may choose to shut down rather than risk the cost that could come from the sale of the owner’s home.

    To sum it all up, where I understand what the government is trying to do, I can also see a danger of them putting the whole Principle Residents Deduction in jeopardy. As it is, buying and selling your home will become more complicated. You will have to keep records showing exactly what you paid, as well as keep records of any major renovations, just in case when time comes to sell there is any possibility you may have to pay tax. One can argue that the real estate market is partially to blame, along with those that are trying to take advantage, but when it comes down to it everyone has to be prepared because these rules will apply to all, not just those who are trying to profit from today’s housing market.

Double J's Tax

Where your taxes are our 
Located conveniently at the corner of 
Stone Church Rd. E. and Upper Ottawa in the Good Life Fitness plaza Hamilton Ontario.
At Double J’s you get many years experience behind every return. We know the new tax rules and how to make them work for you
We offer Triple A service  
Attentive,  Accurate,  and Affordable
Doing your taxes and dealing with the government can be very stressful and intimidating.  We strive to make this small, but important, part of your life easier.
Haven’t filed in a few years?  Not a problem, we can do past years returns,  and even review previous years returns to correct any errors or omissions.
Starting a new business, or even thinking of starting one?  We offer a wide range of services from helping to handle the HST to financial statement and year end tax preparation.
James Lizotte
Have a Question or need to contact us?
Just type it here then press submit
(Please leave contact info if you wish a reply)
Due to the current situation CRA has extended the tax deadline to June 1, 2020.  They have also extended the payment deadline to September 1, 2020.  This means that any amount owing does not have to be paid until that date and there will be no interest charged.
Self Employed deadline is June 15, 2020
Our Address:
1070 Stone Church Rd E. Unit 33
Hamilton, Ontario
L8W 3K8
(Next to the Bombay Grill)
Archived Articles

This is an archive of previous articles written for tax advice just hit the button to the right.
Tax Season Hours

During the current situation our hours have been adjusted.

We are open to clients:
Tuesday, Thursday and Saturday

Our Prices

Basic Returns $60 +HST 
Couples Returns $110 +HST

*Extra charges will apply for returns with excessive data entry and complex returns (ex. rental income, self employed and employment expenses etc.)
We are family owned and operated.  We strive for a family atmosphere in our office so appointments are preferred.
For our returning clients we offer a drop off service.  We complete these within a few days and give you a call when they are ready for pick up.

Due to the changes within our community we are taking the precaution of not accepting any appointments at this time.  We will continue to offer our drop off service to all clients, until further notice.  Any returns dropped off by May 21st, 2020 we guarantee will be complete for the June 1st deadline.  Anything after May 21st we will try our best but can not guarantee it.